Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 97

The simple ‘hot-desk’ equation

Hot-desking is a classic economic phenomenon. For all the hype and discussion it comes down to a very simple equation. A company can reduce its rental expense, but to do this it needs to get its employees to take a pay cut. The pay cut is not in money but rather a reduction in the quality of an employee’s working environment. Economists call this an ‘externality’. My research could discover no facts on the benefits of hot-desking other than rental cost savings.

Hot-desking is sold as a way to break down work cultural barriers, increase collaboration while creating the ‘Office of the Future – Today’. It is a cost saving exercise. Because a very senior executive endorsed the idea, employees are labelled as not having the right cultural values if they show even a hint of disapproval. A totalitarian propaganda machine is in full swing by the time the last photo of the family is removed from the old decommissioned ‘cold’ desk. Centre worker, Cori Girondoudas was docked $3,000 from her pay each year for two years because she repeatedly refused to remove a photograph from her work station. The photograph took her tally of personal items on the desk to four — one above the prescribed limit.

Companies have reported a reduction in rental costs of up to 30% from adopting hot-desking. These enticing savings have to sell it to the employees who suffer an increase in stress and insecurity. Few employees enjoy hot-desking and those who do are often the same people you regret having near you in a cinema, sports game, bus, plane, or marrying into the family.

Hot-desking conveniently ignores the human condition. Humans are territorial, we enjoy a sense of belonging and like a routine. We are also hierarchical. We work hard to get more pay but we also want the corner office. If some spotty graduate comes in early after his gym class and gets the corner desk, we older guys feel pissed off. We will have to seek revenge, in a team building way of course.

Some of you are thinking that I am just an old guy and I need to get with the times. It is true that I sleep better in the same bed each night and the same goes for my desk. It is hard to get 30 minutes sleep if you wake up in a different part of the office having no idea where you are.

But in Ross Gittins’s article on hot-desking, he quotes research that demonstrates that the most important contribution to work place productivity is not collaboration, but individual focus work. In fact, those who can focus on their work in a nesting environment are also better at collaborating.

One of the fundamentals of business is to drive down costs. Businesses are psychopaths and if they can transfer a cost (externality) to the staff then they will. Businesses also suffer from Aspergers. They don’t really understand the human condition, nor do they read body language.

I am now implementing hot-desking in my home office to improve collaboration, break old work habits and enhance productivity. My favourite hot desk is the queen sized one on the top floor. I go there for an hour after lunch to do my best thinking.

Some comments from Donald’s blog:

Geoff

Unfortunately no one is measuring the cost of the reduction in productivity that’s achieved via ‘discretionary effort’. Discretionary effort is that extra bang for the buck that an organisation gets from an employee because they feel good about their job and where they work, importantly employers don’t have to pay money for this, they just have to demonstrate they value their staff. I have spoken with friends, colleagues and customers on this subject and the common factor is that employers are great at measuring the cost savings from hot-desking but don’t attempt to measure at all the loss of discretionary productivity that goes along with it. I wonder if there is a higher turnover rate of staff where hot-desking has been deployed?

Jayne

I would like to add that during flu and cold epidemics, the wonderful world of hot-desking is also introducing us to plagues that seem to move inexorably around the office. If we were truly interested in efficiency we would return to single offices which allow focus, concentration and peace and quiet a la “Quiet: the power of introverts in a world that can’t stop talking”. Awesome read if you want to change your thinking on the value of noisy collaboration.

Christine

I’m a working mum who does school drop-offs in the mornings. By the time I get to the office it’s impossible to get a desk; not even a spot along the anti-social benches against the windows. When I do find a spot, often practically in the toilet, I spend good third of my day pacing up and down the corridor locating my team for face-to-face discussions. Cost cutting? For sure. Murderer of productivity? I’ll say.

 

Donald Hellyer is the former Global Head of Funds and Insurance at National Australia Bank and is Co-Founder of BigFuture.

 

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Australian stocks will crush housing over the next decade, one year on

Last year, I wrote an article suggesting returns from ASX stocks would trample those from housing over the next decade. One year later, this is an update on how that forecast is going and what's changed since.

Australia’s shameful super gap

ASFA provides a key guide for how much you will need to live on in retirement. Unfortunately it has many deficiencies, and the averages don't tell the full story of the growing gender superannuation gap.

9 lessons from 2024

Key lessons include expensive stocks can always get more expensive, Bitcoin is our tulip mania, follow the smart money, the young are coming with pitchforks on housing, and the importance of staying invested.

The 20 most popular articles of 2024

Check out the most-read Firstlinks articles from 2024. From '16 ASX stocks to buy and hold forever', to 'The best strategy to build income for life', and 'Where baby boomer wealth will end up', there's something for all.

2025: Another bullish year ahead for equities?

2024 was a banner year for equities, with a run-up in US tech stocks broadening into a global market rally, and the big question now is whether the good times can continue? History suggests optimism is warranted.

Time to announce the X-factor for 2024

What is the X-factor - the largely unexpected influence that wasn’t thought about when the year began but came from left field to have powerful effects on investment returns - for 2024? It's time to select the winner.

Latest Updates

Shares

Howard Marks warns of market froth

The renowned investor has penned his first investor letter for 2025 and it’s a ripper. He runs through what bubbles are, which ones he’s experienced, and whether today’s markets qualify as the third major bubble of this century.

Property

What to expect from the Australian property market in 2025

The housing market was subdued in 2024, and pessimism abounds as we start the new year. 2025 is likely to be a tale of two halves, with interest rate cuts fuelling a resurgence in buyer demand in the second half of the year.

Superannuation

How to fix the Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme

The scheme has not been updated since it was established and is no longer fit for purpose. Members now find themselves disadvantaged in several important ways versus those in other superannuation funds.

Investment strategies

5 key investment themes for the next decade

AI has helped markets to new highs and rightly dominated news headlines. Yet there are other themes, including niche ones such as gene editing, which are also expected to drive investment returns over the next decade.

Shares

New avenues of growth make 2025 exciting for investors

Investors need to be more discerning this year as headline valuations are high and the economic cycle turns. Dig a little deeper, though, and there are big opportunities in overlooked shares with strong tailwinds.

Investment strategies

The pros and cons of debt recycling strategies

Debt recycling is a powerful strategy for those juggling the seemingly competing goals of debt reduction and building an investment portfolio. Yet it's often misunderstood because it isn't just a single strategy.

Investment strategies

Australia is out of step on nuclear power

Globally, nuclear power is gathering momentum as a differentiated power source in the energy transition to zero carbon emissions. Yet in Australia, a nuclear ban remains, making us an outlier among our Western Allies.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2025 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.