Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 398

Investment forecasts: foresight or folly?

Forecasting is an integral part of the human experience. Almost every key decision we make in life involves some element of guessing at the future; from the suburb in which we buy a property, the studies we undertake and those we might encourage our children to pursue, the career direction we take and, of course, to the investment decisions we make.

We want our financial futures to be as secure as possible, and so it is only to be expected that anyone claiming investment foresight (real or otherwise) will find a willing ear.

We therefore listen attentively to the forecasts of those only too happy to prognosticate on television, the radio or online. And there is, at present, no shortage of investment sages proffering views on everything from the re-emergence of US inflation to the future of fiat currencies.

But how do we, the investing public, determine if any of these predictions are in any way superior to simple guesses? Well, help is at hand.

The Professor of Prescience

Enter Philip E Tetlock. Tetlock is a Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, with appointments across the Wharton Business School, psychology and political science. In 1984 Professor Tetlock embarked on a multi-year research project to understand the nature of expert judgement, studying some 28,000 forecasts made by hundreds of experts across a variety of fields including politics, the economy and finance. His is among the longest, most detailed academic studies of whether humans can actually predict the future with any statistically significant degree of accuracy.

Tetlock pitted the expert forecasts against a range of algorithmically derived forecasts (so-called ‘Clinical’ versus ‘Actuarial’ forecasts). His conclusions at the end of almost 20 years of investigation? “Surveying these scores across regions, time periods, and outcome variables, we find support for one of the strongest debunking predictions: it is impossible to find any domain in which humans clearly outperformed crude extrapolation algorithms, less still sophisticated statistical ones.”

Forecasts made by the experts were statistically indistinguishable from random guesses. This finding subsequently morphed, somewhat unflatteringly, into a metaphor of the average finance guru being no more accurate than a ‘dart-throwing chimp’ in guessing future investment outcomes.

Are investment professionals better forecasters?

OK, so geo-political analysts can’t predict the location and timing of the next military coup. But surely seasoned investment professionals, with all that financial market data at their disposal, can outperform random guesses? One might be tempted to think so.

Unfortunately, the evidence is to the contrary. In a 2015 study of investment analyst forecasts, researchers Marcus Spiwoks, Zulia Gubaydullina and Oliver Hein found that none of the predictions for share markets, interest rates and exchange rates for four countries were able to beat simple forecasts based on a simple ‘random walk’ assumption (that the best guess as to the future state is the current state).

Delving specifically into the forecasting of interest rates, they studied 158,022 4- and 13-month rate predictions across 12 countries only to find that over 98% of the forecasts better reflected rates at the time of making the forecast than at the future date. Hence the name of their paper, “Trapped in the Here and Now – New Insights into Financial Market Analyst Behavior”. In short, there was no noticeable evidence of investment foresight present.

Separating forecasting skill from luck

So how does one determine if an expert’s forecast might suggest a degree of foresight rather than being just a product of luck? You certainly wouldn’t want to ask for examples of his or her forecasting track-record. Why? Because if someone makes enough forecasts, some of them are bound to be proved right. These correct ‘calls’ can then be used as proof of foresight, while the unsuccessful ones go unmentioned in the hope of a quick burial without the possibility of exhumation and further analysis.

Just as a broken clock can still be right twice a day, it can be difficult to know where forecasting skill ends, and luck begins. Without a way of separating the two we’ll never know if a forecaster is lucky but without skill or skilful but unlucky.

Thankfully one such way does exist, and it is remarkably low tech. It involves committing a forecast to paper in an investment diary. But, and this is key, the forecaster must provide both the forecast and an explanation as to why it will eventuate. In this way the forecaster commits to providing a prediction of both cause and effect.

As simple and effective as this technique is, it is roundly ignored by the investment industry. Few investment manager(s) or financial planners are prepared to back their forecasts in such a manner. Fewer clients are prepared to demand they do. That’s a pity as keeping an investment diary is one of the most powerful ways to determine if one is right for the wrong reasons (lucky rather than skilful) or wrong but for the right reasons (skilful but without luck).

If it all sounds a little pedestrian and something that an investment manager or adviser would deem to be beneath them, consider this. One of the world’s most astute investors, hedge fund billionaire George Soros, recalls a period when he recorded all his investment decisions and the reasons behind them in an investment diary. In his words: “I kept a diary in which I recorded the thoughts that went into my investment decisions on a real-time basis. …The experiment was a roaring success in financial terms – my fund never did better. It also produced a surprising result: I came out of the experiment with quite different expectations about the future.”

Learning to sit with irreducible uncertainty

Danish physicist and Nobel prize-winner Niels Bohr is reputed to have once said “Prediction is very difficult, especially if it’s about the future.” What holds true in the sub-atomic world of matter holds doubly true in the world of investing, where the unpredictability of human behaviour, unlike the predictable laws of quantum mechanics, have an outsized effect on outcomes.

View the forecasts of investment gurus and talking heads for what they are, guesstimates. Undoubtedly intelligent and well informed, but guesstimates of an essentially unknown and unknowable future all the same. T’was ever thus.

 

Post-script: Those interested in delving further may wish to avail themselves of a copy of Philip Tetlock and Dan Gardner’s “Superforecasting: The Art and Science of Prediction” Crown Publishers (New York), 2015.

 

Harry Chemay has more than two decades of experience across both wealth management and institutional asset consulting. An active participant within the wealth and superannuation space, Harry is a regular contributor in Australia and overseas, writing on topics across investing, retirement planning and the provision of financial advice.

Harry was a co-founder in one of Australia’s earliest digital advice services, Clover.com.au, and has more recently been appointed an Australian Ambassador to the Transparency Task Force, a UK-led initiative to bring greater transparency and accountability to financial services.

 

  •   10 March 2021
  • 3
  •      
  •   

RELATED ARTICLES

Five steps to become a better investor

Five reasons fund managers don't talk about skill

Smart beta funds complement active without key person risk

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Division 296: the initial moves to make before the windows close

What if the best superannuation strategy isn't about earning more, but acting before your options disappear? Several overlooked planning windows are narrowing, with consequences that can last for decades.

The retirement scorecard: how many of these questions can you answer?

From the maths of retirement, estimating spending and picking the right asset allocation to survive a poor decade, here are the questions every retiree – current or future – should be able to answer for themselves.

Testamentary trusts: Treasury has picked the wrong reading

A decades-old estate planning tool has survived one tax crackdown only to be caught by another. The surprise isn't who the reform is targeting, but who could end up paying the price for drafting choices made years ago.

Superannuation’s structural failings

Politicians are fighting over access to super, but they may be arguing about the wrong thing. The system’s three fundamental flaws have been hiding in plain sight for decades, costing Australians far more than they realise.

Avoid unnecessary CGT with this estate planning clause

A simple estate plan can create a ticking time bomb. One overlooked clause can pit spouses against children, delay inheritances, and potentially leave a family facing an unexpected tax bill worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Does an American retirement rule work for Australians?

The 4% rule has survived decades of scrutiny, but Australia's retirement system changes the equation in ways most overlook. Before accepting or rejecting this rule of thumb, it pays to understand what really drives retirement outcomes.

Latest Updates

Superannuation

Bill Kelty: Super can't solve everyone's problems

One of the key figures behind Australia’s superannuation system reflects on how it began, what has changed, and why some of today’s biggest debates may be asking too much of a retirement savings system.

Investment strategies

Rising yields have put bonds back in business

For the past decade, investors were forced to chase income wherever they could find it. With yields now offering competition to dividends, the new challenge is deciding whether they're still being adequately rewarded for risk.

Strategy

Do you want a bucket with that?

Retirees, advisers and super funds all talk about the bucket strategy as if it's one thing. It's not. The differences can be significant, and some may matter far more than investors realise when markets become volatile.

Investment strategies

What The Odyssey can teach us about valuation discipline

Investment temptations are hard to resist in the moment, but successful investing is not about ignoring compelling opportunities or ideas. For value investors, the smart move is to prepare before momentum clouds judgement.

Shares

Does market concentration really mean more risk for investors?

One of the most closely watched trends in global markets has become a growing source of investor concern in recent years. Whether that concern is justified, however, turns out to be a far more complicated question.

Retirement

Retirement in reality - 8 months in

Health goals, new friendships and lingering questions about identity have dominated this month. The experience has challenged widely held beliefs about purpose, belonging and what it really means to leave work behind.

Shares

Stagnation might be OK at this point

Australia's economic problems are hardly a secret. The more interesting question for investors is whether the stock market is as exposed to those problems as commonly assumed, or whether the picture is more nuanced.

Sponsors

Alliances

  • ASA-Logo-RGB-ActiveGreen-web.png

© 2026 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.