Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 4

Superannuation is losing its lustre

The framework for Australia’s retirement policy set up in 1992 was original and even world-leading. It offered great promise that, once the new arrangements settled in, the retirement needs of our ageing population would be well-provided.

Alas, in recent years, our retirement arrangements, and particularly the superannuation component, have been losing their lustre, because of the many changes in regulations already made and in prospect.

The framework proposed twenty one years ago

The original framework had four components.

First, the taxpayer-funded age pension would continue to provide for a relatively frugal lifestyle and be means-tested. This was in line with the traditional approach in this country to the age pension, but stood in contrast with the higher, and universal, age pensions paid in much of western Europe which, in recent years, have contributed to government financial problems across a lot of Europe.

Second, there would be compulsory contributions into superannuation, mostly paid from employers, with recognition these payments would lessen the rate of increase in average wages. These compulsory contributions would start at 3% of wages and the required minimum would be raised, over time, so that a large proportion of the future retirement needs of middle Australia would come from the compulsory contributions and the accumulated earnings on them.

Third, there would be tax benefits provided for superannuation savings, to boost the return on compulsory contributions and to give some encouragement for voluntary savings in superannuation.

The fourth feature of the proposed retirement arrangements attracted surprisingly little attention at the time: most Australians would have defined contributions superannuation rather than the defined benefits superannuation that traditionally applied to the small proportion of the workforce who had participated in superannuation.

In the future, the amount of superannuation most of us would draw on in retirement would be defined by the amount of contributions paid into our superannuation accounts and the accumulated earnings on those funds.

The retirement framework is not working out as well as was hoped

But 21 years on, the goal of sustainability in Australia’s retirement system is proving to be elusive.

In part, that’s because we are, on average, living much longer and have more years of retirement to fund than was earlier expected. For the most part, that’s a good problem to have. (As average longevity is likely to rise further in the future, let’s make enough allowance for that, both in thinking about future strains in the retirement system and when individuals plan their own retirement).

But there are other and more deep-seated problems. The rules for superannuation keep changing, making it unnecessarily hard for people to plan for their retirement years. For example, there’s the imposition of a cap of $25,000 on the annual tax-favoured contributions into an individual’s superannuation fund (including, of course, the contributions paid by employers on behalf of their employees).

This will prevent many people, particularly parents in their late fifties and sixties who are better placed to save when their offspring have finally left home (some for the third time) from building up enough superannuation to carry them through what could be several decades in retirement.

There have been widespread suggestions that taxation of superannuation will be increased in this year’s budget, in part because the government needs additional revenues to fund existing and proposed spending programmes and in part because the current tax treatment of superannuation is said to unreasonably favour high income groups.

Taxation of superannuation: the main options

Superannuation has four possible taxation points:

  • contributions
  • investment earnings
  • benefits
  • death of the superannuation member

My preference was always to have superannuation taxed when the benefits are paid, whether taken as lump sums or as superannuation pensions.

But the decisions of successive governments have left us with taxation arrangements that run as follows: there’s taxation (at rates of 15% or 30% depending on the income of the contributor) of most money going into superannuation funds; also, investment earnings are taxed while the individual’s superannuation is in accumulation phase; but superannuation benefits paid to people aged over 60 are untaxed; and tax applies to most undrawn, tax-benefited contributions left in the estate of superannuation members when they die (any taxable component of superannuation benefit not paid to a dependent spouse or minor child is taxed at 16.5%).

The exaggerated numbers of taxation foregone

The Federal Treasury publishes figures each year for ‘taxation expenditures’, or how much tax revenue is forgone by existing tax concessions. I have trouble accepting the Treasury’s estimates that $30 billion (and soon to be $40 billion) a year of tax revenue is forgone because of the favoured taxation treatment of superannuation – estimates that the government is using to justify increased taxation of superannuation.

Those calculations make inadequate allowance for the front-ended taxation of superannuation. They assume the $1.5 trillion of assets currently held in superannuation funds would be invested elsewhere with all earnings taxed at marginal rates, and none would be spent or invested in tax-effective ways. In addition, the calculations ignore future collections of tax from estates.

Even without any further tax imposts on superannuation, superannuation isn’t the preferred vehicle for additional retirement savings it was intended to be. Many Australians now find they’d be better off putting further saving for retirement outside rather than within their superannuation account.

An increasing number of Australians will even find they’d improve the after-tax returns on their investments by moving some current savings in superannuation to other categories of their wealth holdings.

What’s needed?

It would be great to see a review and renewal of Australia’s retirement system, with:

  • caps on life-time contributions to superannuation set at a level that permits adequate self-financing of retirement
  • taxation arrangements leaving superannuation as the preferred vehicle for retirement savings
  • fewer year-by-year changes in the design of retirement arrangements
  • the ages for various entitlements to the age pension and superannuation moving up in parallel with average longevity.

Sadly, breathing this new life into the structure of retirement policy would require standards of leadership and bi-partisanship lacking in Australia these days.

 

Don Stammer is an advisor to the Third Link Growth Fund, Altius Asset Management and Philo Capital Management. He writes a weekly column on investments for The Australian newspaper. The views expressed in this column are his alone.

 

RELATED ARTICLES

Super performance test will destroy viability of some funds

Designing a world-class post-retirement system

Super contributions a $1 million opportunity

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 581 with weekend update

A recent industry event made me realise that a 30 year old investing trend could still have serious legs. Could it eventually pose a threat to two of Australia's biggest companies?

  • 10 October 2024

The nuts and bolts of family trusts

There are well over 800,000 family trusts in Australia, controlling more than $3 trillion of assets. Here's a guide on whether a family trust may have a place in your individual investment strategy.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 583 with weekend update

Investing guru Howard Marks says he had two epiphanies while visiting Australia recently: the two major asset classes aren’t what you think they are, and one key decision matters above all else when building portfolios.

  • 24 October 2024

Warren Buffett is preparing for a bear market. Should you?

Berkshire Hathaway’s third quarter earnings update reveals Buffett is selling stocks and building record cash reserves. Here’s a look at his track record in calling market tops and whether you should follow his lead and dial down risk.

Preserving wealth through generations is hard

How have so many wealthy families through history managed to squander their fortunes? This looks at the lessons from these families and offers several solutions to making and keeping money over the long-term.

A big win for bank customers against scammers

A recent ruling from The Australian Financial Complaints Authority may herald a new era for financial scams. For the first time, a bank is being forced to reimburse a customer for the amount they were scammed.

Latest Updates

Property

Coalition's super for housing plan is better than it looks

Housing affordability is shaping up as a major topic as we head toward the next federal election. The Coalition's proposal to allow home buyers to dip into their superannuation has merit, though misses one key feature.

Planning

Avoiding wealth transfer pitfalls

Australia is in the early throes of an intergenerational wealth transfer worth an estimated $3.5 trillion. Here's a case study highlighting some of the challenges with transferring wealth between generations.

Retirement

More people want to delay retirement and continue working

A new survey suggests that most people aged 50 or over don't intend to stop work completely when they reach retirement age. And a significant proportion of those who delay retirement do so for non-financial reasons.

Economy

US debt, the weak AUD and the role of super funds

The more the US needs capital and funding, the higher its currency goes. For Australia, this has become a significant problem as the US draws our capital to sustain its growth, putting pressure on our economy and the Aussie dollar.

Investment strategies

America eats the world

As the S&P 500 rips to new highs, the US now accounts for a staggering two-thirds of the world equity index. This looks at how America came to dwarf other markets, and what could change to slow or halt its momentum.

Gold

What's next for gold?

Despite a recent pullback, gold has been one of the best performing assets this year. What are the key factors behind the rise and what's needed for the bull market in the yellow metal to continue?

Taxation

Consulting on the side? Don't fall into these tax traps

Consultants must be aware of the risks of Personal Service Income rules applying to their income. Especially if they want to split their income or work through a company.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.