Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

What are stock market valuations telling us now?

The concept of value or valuation is central to investing as the cheaper you buy an asset the higher its prospective return might be. However, this is frequently forgotten with investors tempted to project recent returns into the future regardless of valuations and periodically – usually after periods of strong gains – some argue that they don’t matter anymore.

But looking at value now is pertinent as shares have had a good run and on some measures are stretched – particularly US shares. For example, a recent Goldman Sachs study concluded that based on current valuations along with various other variables US shares will return around just 3% pa over the next 10 years.

Cash & bonds offer better returns than three years ago

By its nature valuation is a relative concept usually expressed relative to the income flow an investment will produce. This makes the valuation of cash and bonds relatively simple. But for shares it can get more slippery and for things like gold and Bitcoin it can get really hard as there is no real income.

The good news for cash and bonds is that the rise in interest rates since 2022 has improved their valuations as they are now providing more interest income. That said, term deposit rates are still well below levels around 6-7% in 2010 and have started to soften ahead of RBA rate cuts.


Source: RBA, AMP

For government bonds, their yield is a good guide to starting point value and hence medium-term return potential. If the yield on a 10-year bond is 5%, and you hold the bond to maturity, your return will be 5%. Of course, the relationship is not perfect but it’s a very good guide.

This can be seen in the next chart, which shows a scatter plot of Australian 10-year bond yields since 1950 (horizontal axis) against subsequent 10 year returns from Australian bonds based on the Composite All Maturities Bond index (vertical axis).

When bond yields are low, they set up low bond returns over the medium term and vice versa. For example, at their low point of 0.6% in 2020, 10-year bond yields were pointing to very low returns. At today's 4.5% they are still historically low but point to better returns.


Source: Bloomberg, AMP

For shares, the lower the PE (or the higher the dividend yield) the better

For shares a similar relationship holds. The following chart shows a scatter plot of the price to trailing 12 months earnings ratio for US shares since 1900 (along the horizontal axis) against subsequent 10-year total returns (i.e. dividends plus capital growth) from US shares.

While the relationship is not as smooth as for bonds, as share returns are more complicated, it is a negative relationship. So, when share prices are high compared to earnings, subsequent 10-year returns tend to be low and vice versa.


Source: Bloomberg, AMP

The next chart shows the same for Australian shares from 1962, which is as far back as we have PE data for. Again, the relationship is negative between the level of the PE and subsequent total returns (based on the All Ords Accumulation Index) with the best returns coming after periods of low PEs. At the end of the mid-1970s bear market, for example, the PE was just 5.4 times and shares returned 21.8% pa over the next decade!


Source: RBA, ASX, AMP Capital

There is dividend yield data for Australian shares from 1900 and, as expected, the higher it is the better the subsequent 10-year return.

The key is that the starting point value matters a lot – the higher the yield and the lower the PE (for shares) the better for medium term returns. But behavioural finance tells us that it’s natural for investors to pay too much attention to recent performance. So after a run of strong years investors expect it will continue and fear they will miss out (FOMO) if they don’t get in.

This leads many to buy only after good times, only to find they have bought when shares are overvalued, and they find themselves locked into poor returns. And vice versa after a run of poor returns.

Valuation is not a perfect guide to share returns

Of course, share market valuations can have their own pitfalls.

  • First, you need to allow for risk as sometimes assets are cheap for a reason. This can be an issue with individual shares, e.g. a tobacco company subject to lawsuits even though current earnings are fine.
  • Second, valuation is a poor guide to market timing, often being out by years. Eg, many have pointed out over the last few years that US tech shares are overvalued only to see them keep outperforming.
  • Third, there is a huge array of valuation measures for shares. For example, the “earnings” in the PE can be actual historic earnings as reported for the last 12 months, consensus earnings for the year ahead or earnings that have been smoothed to remove cyclical distortions. All have pros and cons.
  • Finally, the appropriate level of valuation will vary with inflation and interest rates. In times of low inflation, assets can trade on lower yields as the yield structure in the economy falls, uncertainty falls and (for shares) the quality of reported earnings improves. This means higher PEs. The shift from the high inflation and interest rates of the 1970s and 1980s to very low inflation last decade was very positive for shares. But if inflation rises resulting in higher interest rates, this is bad news for shares as we saw in 2022. Fortunately, inflation is now on the way back down again allowing higher PEs.

Current share market valuation signals

It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that rich valuations point to a period of lower returns over the next decade or so for US shares. This is evident in the relationship between PEs and subsequent share market returns seen in the third chart in this note. The current US PE of 26 times points to an average return over the next decade of around 3% pa – see the red lines on the chart (although there’s been a big range around this). 

US share market concentration in IT is a concern as the Goldman Sachs analysis pointed out. IT shares are now nearly as big a share of the US market as they were at the tech boom peak in 2000. This is a concern as it’s hard for a handful of stocks to sustain their strong profit performance. That said, at least tech stocks are earning strong profits now - with Nasdaq on a 41 times PE versus around 100 in early 2000.


Source: Bloomberg, AMP

Similarly, the risk premium the US share market offers over bonds – derived by subtracting the 10-year bond yield from the earnings yield (using forward earnings) – is now zero, which is well below the 3 to 4% offered over much of the period since the GFC.


Source: Bloomberg, AMP

Fortunately, valuations for other share markets are not as stretched:

  • Australian shares are trading on a PE of 21 times. Based on the historic relationship seen in the fourth chart in this note, this points to a medium-term return of around 8% pa. That said, like the US it offers a relatively low risk premium over bonds (see chart above)
  • Eurozone shares are trading on a PE of around 15 times and offer a 4.6% risk premium over German bonds (see chart above).
  • Chinese shares are trading on a PE of around 16 times (and lower depending on the index used) and provide a relatively high risk premium over bonds (see chart above).

Implications for investors

Stretched US market valuations have several implications for investors.

First, they leave shares vulnerable to a fall particularly given that the risk of recession still remains high, the expansion of the war in the Middle East still threatens to impact oil supplies (although Israel’s “restrained” response to Iran’s missile attack points to de-escalation for now) and a Trump victory in the US election will likely spark another trade war.

Second, it provides a reminder that share market returns won’t be sustained at double digit levels indefinitely.

Third, given the relatively stretched nature of the US share market and tech stocks in particular there is a case to consider a reduced allocation to US shares in global share portfolios.

Finally, it’s worth bearing in mind that timing this is likely to be hard. Worries about the US share market’s dependence on tech stocks are not new and they have kept going for longer than many thought.

Our view remains positive for shares on a six-to-12-month view as central banks cut rates and recession is avoided, but stretched valuations in the key US share market point to more constrained returns with higher risk.

 

Dr Shane Oliver is Head of Investment Strategy and Chief Economist at AMP. This article has been prepared for the purpose of providing general information, without taking account of any particular investor’s objectives, financial situation or needs.

 


 

Leave a Comment:


RELATED ARTICLES

US election implications for investors and Australia

Why are some companies vulnerable in 2022?

Shaken by stock market carnage? Forget everything

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

The nuts and bolts of family trusts

There are well over 800,000 family trusts in Australia, controlling more than $3 trillion of assets. Here's a guide on whether a family trust may have a place in your individual investment strategy.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 581 with weekend update

A recent industry event made me realise that a 30 year old investing trend could still have serious legs. Could it eventually pose a threat to two of Australia's biggest companies?

  • 10 October 2024

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 583 with weekend update

Investing guru Howard Marks says he had two epiphanies while visiting Australia recently: the two major asset classes aren’t what you think they are, and one key decision matters above all else when building portfolios.

  • 24 October 2024

Preserving wealth through generations is hard

How have so many wealthy families through history managed to squander their fortunes? This looks at the lessons from these families and offers several solutions to making and keeping money over the long-term.

A big win for bank customers against scammers

A recent ruling from The Australian Financial Complaints Authority may herald a new era for financial scams. For the first time, a bank is being forced to reimburse a customer for the amount they were scammed.

The quirks of retirement planning with an age gap

A big age gap can make it harder to find a solution that works for both partners – financially and otherwise. Having a frank conversation about the future, and having it as early as possible, is essential.

Latest Updates

Investment strategies

Warren Buffett is preparing for a bear market. Should you?

Berkshire Hathaway’s third quarter earnings update reveals Buffett is selling stocks and building record cash reserves. Here’s a look at his track record in calling market tops and whether you should follow his lead and dial down risk.

Economy

US election implications for investors and Australia

The return of Donald Trump to the US presidency brings the prospect of more US tax cuts and deregulation, but also more tariff hikes, trade wars and policy uncertainty. Here's what it means for markets going forward.

Retirement

The rising tension between housing debt and retirement balances

Australians are taking more mortgage debt into their 60s than ever before. Retirement planning assumptions haven’t adapted and could result in future income projections that ultimately disappoint retirees.

Investment strategies

Why megatrends can deliver big upside (and downside)

The magnitude and duration of society's most important trends are often underestimated. While these trends are usually touted as a tailwind, one in particular could have dark consequences for many assets.

Property

Fixing the construction industry house of cards

Australia needs to build new homes like never before but construction firms keep going belly up. Unless regulators act now, consumers will continue to carry the can.

Investment strategies

How investor portfolios have become riskier versus history

Risk in portfolios has dramatically increased as time horizons have shortened and investors have piled into equities. It's resulted in a growing disconnect between what investors need and what the financial industry is delivering.

Shares

The abacus, big data and a brief history of indexing

Equity indices have evolved over time, led by step-changes in our ability to manipulate data. Despite the rise of passive investing, they weren't initially meant to be investment tools.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.